META-ANALYSIS OF THE INFLUENCING FACTORS OF TOURISTS' ENVIRONMENTAL RESPONSIBILITY BEHAVIOR
ZHANG Yuan-gang1, YU Run-zhe2
1. College of Tourism, Shanghai Normal University, Shanghai 200234, China;
2. Faculty of International Tourism and Management, City University of Macau, Macau 999078, China
Abstract：The environmental responsibility behavior of tourists is a hot issue in tourism research, which is more and more important for the sustainable development of tourism destinations. Based on the meta-analysis method and the quantitative research results of domestic scholars, this paper finally selects 27 articles with detailed data and makes a systematic analysis of the relationship intensity of the influencing factors of tourists' environmental responsibility behavior. The results show that: 1) Funnel plot and FSN test show that the samples are representative, and there is no bias. 2) It is verified that place attachment, recreational involvement, attitude, satisfaction, norms, knowledge, and perceived value have significant positive effects on tourists' environmental responsibility behavior. 3) The difference of research sample size shows an obvious moderating effect on the relationship between perceived value, norms, satisfaction, attitudes, and tourists' environmental responsibility. 4) The differences in the types of case studies show a moderating effect on the relationship between place attachment, perceived value, satisfaction, attitude, involvement, knowledge, and tourists' environmental responsibility behaviors. 5) The year differences in the study moderated the relationship between local attachment, attitude, recreational involvement, knowledge, and tourists' environmental responsibility behavior.
Gössling S, Peeters P. Assessing tourism's global environmental impact 1900-2050[J]. Journal of Sustainable Tourism, 2015,23(5):1-21.
[2]
Halpenny E A. Pro-environmental behaviours and park visitors:The effect of place attachment[J]. Journal of Environmental Psychology, 2010,30(4):409-421.
[3]
Deery M, Jago L K, Fredline L, et al. Rethinking social impacts of tourism research:A new research agenda[J]. Tourism Management, 2012,33(1):64-73.
[4]
贾衍菊,林德荣.旅游者环境责任行为:驱动因素与影响机理——基于地方理论的视角[J].中国人口·资源与环境,2015,25(7):161-169.[Jia Yanju, Lin Derong. Influence factors and effects of tourists' environmentally responsible behaviors based on place theory[J]. China Population, Resources and Environment, 2015,25(7):161-169.]
[5]
Lopezmosquera N, Sanchez M. The influence of personal values in the economic-use valuation of peri-urban green spaces:An application of the means-end chain theory[J]. Tourism Management, 2011, 32(4):875-889.
[6]
邱宏亮.旅游节庆意象、节庆依恋、节庆游客环境责任态度与行为——以杭州西溪花朝节为例[J].浙江社会科学,2017(2):84-93,117, 158.[Qiu Hongliang. Tourism festival image, festival attachment, festival tourist's environmentally responsible attitude and behavior:A case of Hangzhou Xixi flower fairy festival[J]. Zhejiang Social Sciences, 2017(2):84-93,117,158.]
[7]
陈虎,梅青,王颖超,等.历史街区旅游意象对环境责任行为的驱动性研究——以满意度为中介变量[J].中国人口·资源与环境,2017, 27(12):106-116.[Chen Hu, Mei Qing, Wang Yingchao, et al. A research on the driving power about environmentally responsible behavior from the destination image of historic blocks:Satisfaction as mediator variable[J]. China Population, Resources and Environment, 2017,27(12):106-116.]
[8]
潘丽丽,王晓宇.基于主观心理视角的游客环境行为意愿影响因素研究——以西溪国家湿地公园为例[J].地理科学,2018,38(8):1337-1345.[Pan Lili, Wang Xiaoyu. The factors affecting the intention to exhibit environmental behavior by tourists:A case study of Xixi national wetland park in Hangzhou[J]. Scientia Geographica Sinica, 2018,38(8):1337-1345.]
[9]
Ramkissoon H, Mavondo F T, Uysal M, et al. Social involvement and park citizenship as moderators for quality-of-life in a national park[J]. Journal of Sustainable Tourism, 2018,26(3):341-361.
[10]
Ballantyne R, Packer J, Falk J H, et al. Visitors' learning for environmental sustainability:Testing short-and long-term impacts of wildlife tourism experiences using structural equation modelling[J]. Tourism Management, 2011,32(6):1243-1252.
[11]
Huang H, Lin T, Lai M, et al. Environmental consciousness and green customer behavior:An examination of motivation crowding effect[J]. International Journal of Hospitality Management, 2014,40(7):139-149.
[12]
Puhakka R. Environmental concern and responsibility among nature tourists in Outlank PAN park, Finland[J]. Scandinavian Journal of Hospitality and Tourism, 2011,11(1):76-96.
[13]
Dolnicar S, Crouch G I, Long P, et al. Environment-friendly tourists:What do we really know about them?[J]. Journal of Sustainable Tourism, 2008,16(2):197-210.
[14]
Steg L, Vlek C. Encouraging pro-environmental behaviour:An integrative review and research agenda[J]. Journal of Environmental Psychology, 2009,29(3):309-317.
[15]
Osbaldiston R, Schott J P. Environmental sustainability and behavioral science meta-analysis of pro-environmental behavior experiments[J]. Environment and Behavior, 2012,44(2):257-299.
[16]
Han H, Hyun S S. Fostering customers' pro-environmental behavior at a museum[J]. Journal of Sustainable Tourism, 2017,25(9):1240-1256.
[17]
Minton A P, Rose R L. The effects of environmental concern on environmentally friendly consumer behavior:Anexploratory study[J]. Journal of Business Research, 1997,40(1):37-48.
[18]
祁潇潇,赵亮,胡迎春.敬畏情绪对旅游者实施环境责任行为的影响——以地方依恋为中介[J].旅游学刊,2018,33(11):110-121.[Qi Xiaoxiao, Zhao Liang, Hu Yingchun. Tourists' awe and environmentally responsible behavior:The mediating role of place attachment[J]. Tourism Tribune, 2018,33(11):110-121.]
[19]
何学欢,胡东滨,粟路军.旅游地居民感知公平、关系质量与环境责任行为[J].旅游学刊,2018,33(9):117-131.[He Xuehuan, Hu Dongbin, Su Lujun. Destination resident's perceived justice, relational quality, and environmentally responsible behavior[J]. Tourism Tribune, 2018,33(9):117-131.]
[20]
张圆刚,程静静,朱国兴,等.古村落旅游者怀旧情感对环境负责任行为的影响机理研究[J].干旱区资源与环境,2019,33(5):190-196.[Zhang Yuangang, Cheng Jingjing, Zhu Guoxing, et al. Research on the influential mechanism of nostalgia, leisure involvement, place attachment and environmentally responsible behavior[J]. Journal of Arid Land Resources and Environment, 2019,33(5):190-196.]
[21]
周玲强,李秋成,朱琳.行为效能、人地情感与旅游者环境负责行为意愿:一个基于计划行为理论的改进模型[J].浙江大学学报(人文社会科学版),2014,44(2):88-98.[Zhou Lingqiang, Li Qiucheng, Zhu Lin. Outcome efficacy, people-destination affect, and tourists' environmentally responsible behavior intention:A revised model based on the theory of planned behavior[J]. Journal of Zhejiang University (Humanities and Social Sciences), 2014,44(2):88-98.]
[22]
吴若云,马宝建,张玉钧.地方性知识需求、地方依恋与环境责任行为关系研究——以三江源国家公园为例[J].中南林业科技大学学报(社会科学版),2019,13(3):23-29.[Wu Ruoyun, Ma Baojian, Zhang Yujun. Research on the relationship among local knowledge demand, place attachment and environmental responsibility behaviors:Take Three-rivers-source national park as an example[J]. Journal of Central South University of Forestry & Technology (Social Sciences), 2019,13(3):23-29.]
[23]
罗文斌,张小花,钟诚,等.城市自然景区游客环境责任行为影响因素研究[J].中国人口·资源与环境,2017,27(5):161-169.[Luo Wenbin, Zhang Xiaohua, Zhong Cheng, et al. Research on the influencing factors of tourists' environmental responsibility behavior in urban natural scenic spots[J]. China Population, Resources and Environment, 2017,27(5):161-169.]
[24]
王华,李兰.生态旅游涉入、群体规范对旅游者环境友好行为意愿的影响——以观鸟旅游者为例[J].旅游科学,2018,32(1):86-95[Wang Hua, Li Lan. On the impact of eco-tourism involvement and in-group norm on environment-friendly tourist behaviors:A case study of bird-watching tourists[J]. Tourism Science, 2018,32(1):86-95.]
[25]
黄静波,范香花,黄卉洁.生态旅游地游客环境友好行为的形成机制——以莽山国家级自然保护区为例[J].地理研究,2017,36(12):2343-2354.[Huang Jingbo, Fan Xianghua, Huang Huijie. Formation of tourists' environmentally friendly behavior in ecotourism destinations:A case from Mangshannational nature reserve[J]. Geographical Research, 2017,36(12):2343-2354.]
[26]
范香花,黄静波,程励,等.生态旅游者旅游涉入对环境友好行为的影响机制[J]. 经济地理,2019,39(1):225-232.[Fan Xianghua, Huang Jingbo, Cheng Li, et al. The influence mechanism of tourist involvement on environmentally friendly behavior of eco-tourists[J]. Economic Geography, 2019,39(1):225-232.]
[27]
李秋成,周玲强.社会资本对旅游者环境友好行为意愿的影响[J]. 旅游学刊,2014,29(9):73-82.[Li Qiucheng, Zhou Lingqiang. The impact of social capital on tourists' intention to exhibit environment-friendly behaviors[J]. Tourism Tribune, 2014,29(9):73-82.]
[28]
李文明,殷程强,唐文跃,等.观鸟旅游游客地方依恋与亲环境行为——以自然共情与环境教育感知为中介变量[J].经济地理,2019, 39(1):215-224.[Li Wenming, Yin Chengqiang, Tang Wenyue, et al. Place attachment and pro-environmental behaviors of bird-watching tourists:Taking natural empathy and perception of environmental education as mediating variables[J]. Economic Geography, 2019, 39(1):215-224.]
[29]
张安民,李永文.游憩涉入对游客亲环境行为的影响研究——以地方依附为中介变量[J].中南林业科技大学学报(社会科学版), 2016,10(1):70-78.[Zhang Anming, Li Yongwen. Impact of recreation involvement on tourist pro-environmental behaviors:Takingplace attachment as a meditative variable[J]. Journal of Central South University of Forestry Technology (Social Sciences Edition), 2016,10(1):70-78.]
[30]
洪学婷,张宏梅,黄震方,等.旅游体验前后日常环境行为对具体地点环境行为的影响——以大学生黄山旅游体验为例[J].人文地理,2019,34(3):146-153.[Hong Xueting, Zhang Hongmei, Huang Zhenfang, et al. Site-specific environmentally responsible behavior pre and post visit:A case study of Huangshan mountain[J]. Human Geography, 2019,34(3):146-153.]
[31]
洪学婷,张宏梅,张业臣.旅游体验对旅游者环境态度和环境行为影响的纵向追踪研究[J].自然资源学报,2018,33(9):1642-1656.[Hong Xueting, Zhang Hongmei, Zhang Yechen. Influence of tourism experience on environmental attitude and behavior:A longitudinal tracking study[J]. Journal of Natural Resources, 2018,33(9):1642-1656.]
[32]
夏凌云,于洪贤,王洪成,等.湿地公园生态教育对游客环境行为倾向的影响——以哈尔滨市5个湿地公园为例[J].湿地科学,2016, 14(1):72-81.[Xia Lingyun, Yu Hongxian, Wang Hongcheng, et al. Impact of eco-education on visitor's environmental behavior intentions in wetland park:A case study of 5 wetland parks in Harbin[J]. Wetland Science, 2016,14(1):72-81.]
[33]
仇梦嫄,张捷,张宏磊,等.基于旅游声景认知的游客环保行为驱动机制研究——以厦门鼓浪屿为例[J].旅游学刊,2017,32(11):105-115.[Qiu Mengyuan, Zhang Jie, Zhang Honglei, et al. The driving mechanism of tourists' pro-environment behavior based on cognition of tourism soundscapes:A case of Kulangsu[J]. Tourism Tribune, 2017,32(11):105-115.]
[34]
贾衍菊,孙凤芝,刘瑞.旅游目的地依恋与游客环境保护行为影响关系研究[J].中国人口·资源与环境,2018,28(12):159-167.[Jia Yanju, Sun Fengzhi, Liu Rui. Research on the relationship of destination attachment and tourists' environmentally protection behaviors[J]. China Population, Resources and Environment, 2018,28(12):159-167.]
[35]
王屏,戴年华,欧阳雪莲,等.中西方森林游憩者生态行为影响研究——基于解说驱动机制视角[J].生态学报,2016,36(12):3666-3677.[Wang Ping, Dai Nianhua, Ouyang Xuelian, et al. Chinese and Western forest recreationists' ecological behavior from the perspective of the driving mechanisms of interpretation[J]. Acta Ecologica Sinica, 2016,36(12):3666-3677.]
[36]
余及斌.生态旅游涉入、地方依恋与环境负责任行为关系研究——以西溪湿地为例[D].杭州:浙江大学,2015.[Yu Jibin. Study on the Relationship among Eco-Tourism Involvement, Place Attachment and Environmentally Responsible Behavior:A Case Study of Xixi Wetland Park[D]. Hangzhou:Zhejiang University, 2015.]
[37]
余晓婷.游客环境责任行为及其驱动因素研究——以台湾岛为例[D].南京:南京大学,2015.[Yu Xiaoting. Tourists' Environmentally Responsible Behavior and Its Driving Factors:A Case Study of Taiwan Island[D]. Nanjing:Nanjing University, 2015.]
[38]
张琼锐,王忠君.基于TPB的游客环境责任行为驱动因素研究——以北京八家郊野公园为例[J].干旱区资源与环境,2018,32(3):203-208.[Zhang Qiongrui, Wang Zhongjun. Study on the driving factors of tourists' environmentally responsible behavior based on the theory of planned behavior:A case study of Beijing Bajia country park[J]. Journal of Arid Land Resources and Environment, 2018, 32(3):203-208.]
[39]
纪红叶.游客感知价值、地方依恋与环境负责行为的关系研究——以南京钟山风景区为例[D].南京:南京农业大学,2016.[Ji Hongye. A Study on the Relationship among Perceived Value Place Attachment and Environmentally Responsible Behavior:A Case of Zhongshan Scenic Area[D]. Nanjing:Nanjing Agricultural University, 2016.]
[40]
Chow K, Healey M. Place attachment and place identity:First-year undergraduates making the transition from home to university[J]. Journal of Environmental Psychology, 2008,28(4):362-372.
[41]
Manzo L C. Beyond home and haven:Toward a revisioning of emotional relationships with places[J]. Journal of Environmental Psychology, 2003,23(1):47-61.
[42]
Zaichkowsky J L. Measuring the involvement construct[J]. Journal of Consumer Research, 1985,12(3):341-352.
[43]
Zaichkowsky J L. The personal involvement inventory:Reduction, revision, and application to advertising[J]. Journal of Advertising, 1994,23(4):59-70.
[44]
French D P, Sutton S, Hennings S J. The importance of affective beliefs and attitudes in the theory of planned behaviour:Predicting intention to increase physical activity[J]. Journal of Applied Social Psychology, 2005,35(9):1824-1848.
[45]
De Groot J I, Steg L. Morality and prosocial behavior:The role of awareness, responsibility and norms in the norm activation model[J]. Journal of Social Psychology, 2009,71(4):425-449.
[46]
Kollmuss A, Agyeman J. Mind the gap:Why do people act environmentally and what are the barriers to pro-environmental behavior?[J]. Environmental Education Research, 2002,8(3):239-260.
[47]
Zeithaml V A. Consumer perceptions of price, quality, and value:A means-end model and synthesis of evidence[J]. Journal of Marketing, 1988,52(3):2-22.
[48]
Chen Z, Dubinsky A J. A conceptual model of perceived customer value in e-commerce:A preliminary investigation[J]. Psychology & Marketing, 2003,20(4):323-347.
[49]
孔艺丹,黄子璇,陶卓民,等.基于乡村性感知的游客环境责任行为影响机制研究——以南京市江宁区为例[J].南京师大学报(自然科学版),2019,42(1):124-131.[Kong Yidan, Huang Zixuan, Tao Zhuomin, et al. Study on the influence mechanism of tourists' environmentally responsible behavior based on perception of rurality:A case study of Jiangning district of Nanjing city[J]. Journal of Nanjing Normal University (Natural Science Edition), 2019,42(1):124-131.]
[50]
Glass G V. Primary, secondary, and meta-analysis of research[J]. Educational Researcher, 1976,5(10):3-8.
[51]
Borenstein M, Hedges L V, Higgins J P, et al. A basic introduction to fixed-effect and random-effects models for meta-analysis[J]. Research Synthesis Methods, 2010,1(2):97-111.
[52]
Cohen J. A power primer[J]. Psychological Bulletin, 1992,3(2):155-159.
[53]
Rosenberg M, Sadams D C, Gurevitch J. Meta win:Statistical software for meta-analysis with resampling tests[J]. Quarterly Review of Biology, 1998,73(1):126-128.
[54]
Rosenthal R. Meta-analytic procedures for social science research[J]. Educational Researcher, 1986,15(8):18-20.
[55]
Anzures-Cabrera J, Higgins J P. Graphical displays for meta-analysis:An overview with suggestions for practice[J]. Research Synthesis Methods, 2010,1(1):66-80.
